GitHub Copilot
A Tier · 8.3/10
AI code assistant that lives in your editor -- autocomplete on steroids. As of 2026-04-20 new signups for Pro/Pro+/Student are PAUSED. As of 2026-04-27 GitHub announced ALL plans transition to usage-based billing (AI Credits + token metering) effective 2026-06-01 -- code completions remain free, agent/chat usage now meters against monthly credit allotments matching the plan price
Score Breakdown
The Good and the Bad
What we like
- +Inline code completions feel magical -- it predicts what you're about to type with scary accuracy
- +Works directly in VS Code, JetBrains, Neovim -- no context switching
- +Copilot Chat is great for explaining code, writing tests, and debugging
- +Free tier is functional enough for personal projects
What could be better
- −Suggestions can be confidently wrong -- it'll autocomplete plausible-looking code that has subtle bugs
- −Sometimes suggests code that's clearly copied from public repos, raising licensing questions
- −Context window for chat is smaller than standalone tools like Claude
- −Multi-file refactoring understanding is limited compared to Cursor
Pricing
Free
- ✓2,000 completions/mo
- ✓50 chat messages/mo
- ✓VS Code + JetBrains
- ✓Still open to new signups (2026-04-20)
Pro
- ✓NEW SIGNUPS PAUSED 2026-04-20
- ✓Claude Opus REMOVED (Opus 4.7 now Pro+ only)
- ✓Effective 2026-06-01: $10 in monthly AI Credits replaces premium-request quota
Pro+
- ✓NEW SIGNUPS PAUSED 2026-04-20
- ✓Claude Opus 4.7 access
- ✓Full frontier-model picker
- ✓Effective 2026-06-01: $39 in monthly AI Credits
Business
- ✓Organization management
- ✓Policy controls
- ✓Audit logs
- ✓Effective 2026-06-01: $19 in monthly AI Credits per user
Enterprise
- ✓Org-wide governance + SSO
- ✓Effective 2026-06-01: $39 in monthly AI Credits per user
- ✓Standard token metering above the allotment
Known Issues
- TWO MORE MODEL DEPRECATIONS (announced 2026-05-08): (1) **Grok Code Fast 1 retires 2026-05-15** -- only T-7 from announcement, accelerated 'due to the model provider deprecation' on xAI's side. Affects Copilot Chat, inline edits, ask + agent modes, code completions. Replacement: GPT-5 mini or Claude Haiku 4.5. If you have Grok Code Fast 1 pinned in any team config, it stops working in a week. (2) **GPT-4.1 retires 2026-06-01** -- joins the GPT-5.2 + GPT-5.2-Codex 6/1 batch already documented. Replacement: GPT-5.5. Adds to the broader 6/1 usage-based-billing transition cliff: by June 1, model lineup loses GPT-5.2, GPT-5.2-Codex, GPT-4.1, AND moves to AI Credits metering simultaneouslySource: GitHub Changelog (github.blog/changelog/2026-05-08-upcoming-deprecation-of-grok-code-fast-1, github.blog/changelog/2026-05-08-upcoming-deprecation-of-gpt-4-1) · 2026-05-08
- MODEL LINEUP SHRINK (2026-05-07): GitHub Copilot retires Claude Sonnet 4 from its model lineup, mirroring the upstream Anthropic API retirement scheduled for 2026-06-15. If your Copilot org/team had pinned Sonnet 4, it is now unselectable -- migrate to Sonnet 4.6 (1x multiplier, same as Sonnet 4) or Opus 4.7 (15x multiplier, dramatically higher cost). Adds to the 2026-06-01 GPT-5.2 + GPT-5.2-Codex deprecation already documentedSource: GitHub Changelog (github.blog/changelog), Anthropic deprecations page · 2026-05-07
- MULTI-CHANGE BATCH heading into 2026-06-01 billing cutover (vendor-primary verified 2026-05-04): (1) GPT-5.2 + GPT-5.2-Codex DEPRECATION announced 2026-05-01 -- both retired across all Copilot experiences (Chat, inline edits, ask + agent modes, code completions) on 2026-06-01, except GPT-5.2-Codex remains in Copilot Code Review temporarily. Migrate to GPT-5.5 (7.5x multiplier) or GPT-5.4 (1x). (2) Business self-serve signup PAUSED 2026-04-22 -- joining Pro/Pro+/Student paused since 4/20. New Business orgs get Free or Team only; existing Business customers unaffected. (3) Copilot Code Review begins consuming GitHub Actions minutes on 2026-06-01 alongside the existing premium-request charge -- code reviews now bill TWICE (review request + Actions runtime). Budget impact for teams running review on every PR. (4) Verified multiplier table (paid plans, docs.github.com/en/copilot/concepts/billing/copilot-requests as of 2026-05-04): Claude Opus 4.7 = 15x; Claude Opus 4.6 = 3x (fast-mode preview = 30x); Sonnet 4/4.5/4.6 = 1x; Haiku 4.5 = 0.33x; Gemini 3.1 Pro = 1x; Gemini 3 Flash = 0.33x; GPT-5.5 = 7.5x; GPT-5.4 = 1x; GPT-5.4 mini = 0.33x; GPT-5.4 nano = 0.25x; GPT-5.3-Codex = 1x. Aggregator-circulated 'Opus 4.7 = 27x' and 'Gemini 3.1 Pro = 6x' figures are WRONG vs vendor primarySource: GitHub Blog (github.blog/changelog/2026-05-01-upcoming-deprecation-of-gpt-5-2-and-gpt-5-2-codex), (github.blog/changelog/2026-04-22-pausing-new-self-serve-signups-for-github-copilot-business), (github.blog/changelog/2026-04-27-github-copilot-code-review-will-start-consuming-github-actions-minutes-on-june-1-2026), docs.github.com Copilot multiplier table · 2026-05-04
- PRICING REFORM ANNOUNCED 2026-04-27 (effective 2026-06-01): All Copilot paid plans transition off the 'premium requests' metering system to a usage-based AI Credits model. Each tier's monthly price now ALSO becomes its monthly credit allotment ($10 Pro = $10 in credits; $39 Pro+ = $39 in credits; $19 Business = $19/user; $39 Enterprise = $39/user). Above the allotment, requests pay-as-you-go at standard token API rates (input + output + cached). Code completions and Next Edit suggestions remain free across all plans and DO NOT consume credits. Annual subscribers stay on the existing premium-request model until their current plan expires, then drop to Free with a one-time prorated credit transfer covering remaining value. This is a direct response to agent-workload economics that VP Joe Binder cited as the reason for the 4/20 signup pauseSource: GitHub Blog: 'GitHub Copilot is moving to usage-based billing' (github.blog/news-insights/company-news/github-copilot-is-moving-to-usage-based-billing/) · 2026-04-27
- CRITICAL (2026-04-20): GitHub paused NEW signups for Copilot Pro, Pro+, and Student plans. Copilot Free remains open. Existing subscribers keep access but face tightened usage caps -- VP Joe Binder cited agent workloads consuming more compute than subscription economics support. Refund window for dissatisfied subscribers: 2026-04-20 through 2026-05-20 via GitHub Support. If you were planning to buy Pro or Pro+, you currently cannot. Cursor, Claude Code, and Windsurf are the obvious alternatives during the pauseSource: GitHub Changelog (github.blog/changelog/2026-04-20), The Register, AfterDawn · 2026-04
- Claude Opus models were pulled from the Pro tier on 2026-04-20. Opus 4.7 remains on Pro+ only; Opus 4.5 and 4.6 are being removed from Pro+ as well. If you specifically subscribed to Pro for Opus access, your tier has materially changed -- the $10 Pro plan now routes to GPT-5.4 + Gemini 3.1 + smaller open models by defaultSource: GitHub Changelog 2026-04-20, AfterDawn · 2026-04
- EFFECTIVE 2026-04-24 (yesterday): GitHub now trains its AI models on Copilot Free/Pro/Pro+ interaction data by default -- inputs, outputs, code snippets, file names, navigation patterns, and chat comments. Business + Enterprise plans remain excluded. To opt out: settings > Copilot > Features > 'Allow GitHub to use my data for AI model training' (toggle off). Users who previously opted out of product-improvement data collection have that preference preserved. Big differentiator vs. Cursor and Claude Code, both of which do NOT train on user code by defaultSource: GitHub blog (github.blog/news-insights/company-news/updates-to-github-copilot-interaction-data-usage-policy/), The Register · 2026-04-24
- New 'premium requests' currency system rolled out in early 2026 -- Pro plan now gets 300 premium requests/mo, Business 1,500, Enterprise 1,000. Beyond those quotas, requests pay-as-you-go. Check the new plan details page before assuming legacy 'unlimited chat' behavior still appliesSource: GitHub Copilot plans page · 2026-03
- Agent mode reached GA on VS Code and JetBrains in March 2026 -- Copilot can now run multi-step agentic workflows rather than just reply to chat messages. Still behind Cursor Composer 2 and Claude Code on autonomous multi-file work but closes the gap meaningfullySource: GitHub Copilot blog · 2026-03
- Copilot chat occasionally loses context mid-conversation in larger projects, giving irrelevant suggestionsSource: GitHub Community Discussions · 2026-03
Best for
Existing Copilot subscribers on Business/Enterprise or grandfathered Pro/Pro+ seats. Also new Free-tier users -- the entry point is still open and inline completions are still best-in-class.
Not for
Anyone trying to sign up for Pro, Pro+, or Student right now -- signups are paused (2026-04-20 onward). Also not for developers who specifically wanted Claude Opus on the $10 Pro plan; Opus was just pulled to Pro+ only. Cursor or Claude Code are the obvious alternatives during the pause.
Our Verdict
GitHub Copilot hit a wall on 2026-04-20: new Pro/Pro+/Student signups paused, Claude Opus pulled from Pro, and usage caps tightened across the board. Microsoft is openly admitting that agent workloads consume more compute than the current subscription tiers can sustain, and the product is being retuned in real time. For existing subscribers the inline completions remain best-in-class, but the value proposition has gotten worse overnight. If you're shopping for an AI code assistant in the next 30 days, Cursor (Pro+ $60) and Claude Code are the practical choices until Microsoft either reopens signups or reprices. Watch the refund window (through 2026-05-20) if you're on the fence about staying.
Sources
- GitHub Changelog: GPT-5.2 + GPT-5.2-Codex deprecation (2026-05-01, retiring 2026-06-01) (accessed 2026-05-04)
- GitHub Changelog: Business self-serve signup pause (2026-04-22) (accessed 2026-05-04)
- GitHub Changelog: Code Review Actions minutes billing (2026-04-27, effective 2026-06-01) (accessed 2026-05-04)
- GitHub docs: Copilot requests + multiplier table (accessed 2026-05-04)
- GitHub Blog: Copilot moving to usage-based billing (2026-04-27, effective 2026-06-01) (accessed 2026-04-30)
- GitHub Changelog 2026-04-20: Copilot plan changes for individuals (accessed 2026-04-21)
- The Register: GitHub grounds Copilot account creation (accessed 2026-04-21)
- AfterDawn: Usage limits + Opus removal (accessed 2026-04-21)
- GitHub Copilot plans (accessed 2026-04-21)
- GitHub blog: Copilot interaction data usage policy update (effective 2026-04-24) (accessed 2026-04-25)
- GitHub: Copilot Pro/Business training policy (accessed 2026-04-21)
Explore more GitHub Copilot rankings
Deeper leaderboards, benchmarks, task-specific tier lists, and status/pricing pages for GitHub Copilot.
The Tier List Tuesday
Weekly newsletter: tier movers, new entrants, and the VS of the week. Built from our daily AI-tool sweeps. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Alternatives to GitHub Copilot
Cursor
AI-native code editor, now agent-first in Cursor 3 -- multi-workspace, cross-platform agents, and Composer 2 (Cursor's own 200+ tok/s coding model)
Windsurf
Cognition's AI code editor -- Windsurf 2.0 (launched 2026-04-15) adds Agent Command Center, Spaces, and embedded Devin cloud agents. Directly competitive with Cursor 3
Tabnine
AI code completion that runs locally and keeps your code private -- the enterprise-friendly alternative to Copilot
Claude Code
Anthropic's terminal-based coding agent that reads your whole repo and makes real changes -- not just suggestions. v2.1.131 (2026-05-06 Code with Claude conf) shipped Code Review GA + Remote Agents + CI Auto-Fix + Routines, plus 2x rate-limit increase from the SpaceX compute deal
Lovable
Describe the app you want in plain English and watch it build itself -- 8M users and $400M+ ARR say it works
Devin
The most autonomous AI coding agent -- Devin 2.2 (Feb 24 2026) adds desktop/GUI testing (Figma, browser automation), Devin Review (pull-request analysis catching ~30% more issues), and ~3x faster startup (~15s vs ~45s). Now embedded in Windsurf 2.0
Replit
Cloud IDE with an AI agent that can build full apps from prompts -- coding optional, but recommended
Codex (OpenAI)
OpenAI's cloud-based coding agent -- runs parallel tasks, proposes PRs, and lives inside ChatGPT
Google Antigravity
Google's agent-first AI IDE -- deploys up to 5 autonomous coding agents in parallel on a VS Code fork
Codestral 2 (Mistral)
Mistral's dedicated code model -- Codestral 2 (launched 2026-04-08) relicensed under Apache 2.0, removing the commercial-use restrictions of the original. 22B dense, strong FIM (fill-in-middle), available via Mistral API + Hugging Face
Roblox Assistant
Roblox Studio's agentic AI that plans, builds, and playtests games. Planning Mode (2026-04-16) + Mesh Generation + Procedural Models brings 3D-native creation to 70M+ daily creators